Jorge Fonseca (FAO): “The consumer has the power to change the unsustainability of the food system”

Jorge Fonseca is Programme Adviser of Food Systems Strategic Programme at Food & Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). He’s an expert in food science and technology, packaging science, horticulture, agronomy, business administration, marketing and food governance and society. He has authored over 150 scientific and technical publications that address different aspects of food systems, particularly targeting issues of interest for the agri-food industries with one publication receiving a US national press award.

His latest work focuses on assisting United Nations member countries with developing sustainable, efficient and inclusive mechanisms to produce, transform and deliver healthy and safe food to consumers, both in rural and urban areas. He has a passion for contributing to solve food security and nutrition issues in a systemic way, emphasizing on the need to reach all with feasible elements to adopt diversified diets with the lowest environmental impact possible, and a balanced rural-urban economic growth.

Fonseca has been one of the professors of the two-week PhD Autumn school on Sustainable Land Use that had taken place in Budapest and Valencia.

Short food supply chains have positive economic, social and environmental impacts which contribute to the wellbeing of stakeholders by creating secure jobs and stable incomes for farmers, limiting waste within the food chain and negative impacts on the environment while providing healthy, nutrient-rich food to communities. Through analyzing real-life case studies, you will have the opportunity to explore the links within a short food supply chain, identify barriers and solutions for overcoming them. 

Which are the main challenges related to food at global level?

An immense challenge is to be able to converge the interests of all the people involved in the food system. In a clearer way, the interests of consumers with the interests of producers.

Many times, when we talk about the justice of the food system we think only of the producers, or only of the consumers. Finding sustainable routes that encompass everyone is very difficult.

And how can we achieve this?

The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) speak of partnership and that we must all come together to find context-based solutions. We need to involve all stakeholders, not just the food system.

The second challenge is how to make the food system part of global sustainable development. It must not be seen as something separate that we can tackle without touching on aspects such as infrastructure, transport, social security or migration. The great idea of SDGs is to think in a systemic way. We must ensure that the world’s most important decision-makers really see the food system as part of the global system. We are on our way to achieving this. If we’re going to do it, I don’t know.

The third is related to the implementation of the actions. Achieving solidarity between the different parties, especially between those who have more economic power with those who have less, both in the export market and in the domestic market. Solidarity also means a good public-private partnership, being able to create ideal mechanisms to achieve this human solidarity through the food system. And with this, we will be able to reach so many people who are unable to pay for the added value that we are often adding to food.

May be doing distinction among developed and developing countries

The industrialized world has greater economic power so it can influence the way food is produced. If the demand for more sustainable products grows, I think we can achieve the more sustainable production we are looking for. This power of the private sector, which is continuously related to consumers, has in its hand the power to change the unsustainability of the food system.

And how can we persuade the industry to react to adapt to these sustainability needs?

It’s the million dollar question. Who has the power, who is paying, or is the offer the one that can change that demand? It has been seen that supply can change demand. In many places there was no certain type of food and when a type of food was introduced, which in many cases were not nutritious, we see how they now only eat that.

You can do educational campaigns, but it is also true that campaigns to promote certain products are also very strong.  I also understand the position of the private sector. Some are already changing with regard to social and environmental responsibility, but not all are doing so. The public sector must make a standardized regulation so that those who do want to change in the private sector force those who don’t want to. And education is very crucial in order to change behaviour.

Is FAO considering climate change from adaptation but also mitigation point of view? Carbon footprint?

Absolutely, there are many programs focused on intelligent climate technologies. We also support agroecology. We are very interested in biodiversity at FAO because nowadays, with the expansion of the urban area, we are losing very rich biodiversity. It is in the soil that we have the greatest biodiversity on the planet.

I come from a country like Costa Rica, where 30 years ago at least 12 or 15 varieties of pineapple were easily eaten. In the 90’s suddenly changed to 2 or 3 varieties, no longer so acidic. And now there is only one variety, the same variety that you eat here. What are we doing to respond to the massive use of monoculture while we are losing biodiversity?

Biodiversity also affects the variety of the diet. We are working with consumers to educate them that more diverse diets are required, not only for human health but also for the health of the planet.

We have everything against us. If we look at the voluntary official standards of agricultural agencies and the quality classifications of fresh produce such as fruits and vegetables, we almost always find only 2 or 3 qualities. When a fruit has a spot larger than 5 centimeters, it is already disposable. And in some cases, it cannot be marketed.

Exceptions have sometimes been made, such as in the case of some US green apple producers where it was impossible to find apples of that particular variety without spots, despite having a very high production. These growers achieved an exception with this apple variety.

We need to review some standards in many cases and civil society needs to put more pressure on this issue because a lot of produce is staying in the fields.

But for that we also need the support of the scientific community. These standards are aimed at product safety, to prevent fruit from carrying a virus or a bacteria. It is the Academia and research which must help us to assess in which cases there is no danger of harmlessness and in these cases there is.

 And the same applies to chemicals…

The use of chemicals is linked to the following question: Are we paying what we should really be paying for food?

There is a program called the Global Environmental Facility that offers money to stop the producer from using certain highly polluting products that in some cases have already been removed from the regulations but in many cases are still being used. But you can’t convince a small producer to say: You can’t use this anymore, you have to use what is less polluting if you don’t give it a good alternative and that’s always a better price. If they know they are going to keep getting the same price, they don’t understand any other way. It is very difficult when they are making so little money.

And then we go back into consumer education who have to understand that they have to pay more for certain products. And let it be fair. And the intermediaries should be aware that the producer’s price has to be a little higher.

Are fresh products too expensive for the general population ? Should healthy products be subsidized?

We work to be efficient, fair and at the same time maintain high biodiversity at low prices. Non-nutritious products have lowered prices tremendously. Some countries are beginning to alarm about what we are eating. Chile or Ecuador are doing campaigns very similar to anti-tobacco campaigns warning about foods with high fat, sugar and salt content. And it has begun to have an impact. Even though they are cheaper.

The problem has been that products with low nutritional value have dropped a lot in price, so the other very expensive ones are perceived. Because society has focused a lot on things other than food and food has become just another commodity.

What are the problems you have identified in short food supply chains?

There are several problems. One is good communication between local governments and support for the national government. But above all it is to agree on aspects that are interfering for both. When the local government of the largest urban part is a good leader there is not so much problem. But when we talk about intermediate cities, neighbouring and with rural areas, the dialogue is not always so good. If you want to promote productive sustainable corridors, the first thing you have to agree on is water resource planning. This generates tension many times because water is not only the jurisprudence of one government, but of several, and the struggle between the urban and the rural is created.

Another problem is that in some cases the cheapest brings the product from outside. And this struggle means that many times this transition is not achieved in order to sufficiently exploit the potential of short chains.

On the other hand, if there is good cooperation among producers to create associations or cooperatives, it is much easier to promote this internal market, because they function as a large company. And we have seen exemplary cases to be able to achieve this internal production. In some cases, for example, in Thailand, improving domestic production allowed them to generate a good image for export abroad as well. A distribution food chain that is highly productive does not always arise from products for export. There are other cases where domestic demand is key.

Another aspect is the education or awareness of consumers that the local is not only good in terms of nutrition but also has a positive social message, which is to keep their rural area healthy.

And what role does urban agriculture play, can it contribute to the sustainability of cities?

When we talk about urban agriculture, not peri-urban agriculture, we are talking about cities of considerable size. We also have to consider that in cities of this size in the non-industrialized world there are not the same sanitary conditions that exist here. They don’t have enough water to produce. And if they produce there are serious health risks. There have been many cases of people having problems with products that have been produced in urban areas.

Another aspect is that urban agriculture has great potential to support food security. However, production levels are quite low.

If we look at it from the point of view of essential nutrients that do not come in meat products or products such as cereals, it is already contributing something there, because many times fruits and vegetables are not being consumed and in this way many talks about this type of practice promoting healthy eating.

In this sense, perhaps the greatest contribution (and reflected in the FAO book together with University College London, “Integrating food into urban planning”) urban agriculture is the gateway to citizen awareness. The re-encounter with land, vegetables and the rural area, and that made a movement in several cities that then moved to markets and ways of providing food.

Another factor of urban agriculture is the fact that it contributes much to the resilience of many vulnerable areas of cities as well. Especially if they are planting perennial trees.

In this sense, urban forests play an essential role…

At FAO, we are well aware that the urban forest is vital and we have placed it as part of the overall urban food action programme, because we believe that if we focus on people’s well-being, it is not only where they are going to eat but also where they are going to walk. There is a quarter of the world’s population that has nothing around it but 24-hour pollution.

In addition, there is a lot of evidence that urban forests allow for lower energy consumption, maintain higher water table levels, aid mental health and improve air quality.

We wanted to include it in a programme linked to the food and green environment programme. If a person has few economic resources should at least have that, it should be part of the essential.

 
Location
Articles you may be interested in
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
Madrid, Amsterdam and Milan: Three cities putting citizen participation at the...

The Extinction Rebellion or Fridays for Future global actions...

Madrid, Amsterdam and Milan: Three cities putting citizen participation at the heart of climate action
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
Partnering with EIT Climate-KIC on the New Accelerator: Call for Expressions o...

We are looking for new and existing EIT Climate-KIC...

Partnering with EIT Climate-KIC on the New Accelerator: Call for Expressions of Interest
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
EIT Climate-KIC leads collective efforts to accelerate Madrid’s transition t...

A cross- KIC (Knowledge and Innovation Community) initiative is...

EIT Climate-KIC leads collective efforts to accelerate Madrid’s transition towards carbon neutrality
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
Young Innovators organiza dos talleres para profesorado en España

El programa Young Innovators de EIT Climate-KIC en colaboración...

Young Innovators organiza dos talleres para profesorado en España
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
New online magazine Branch explores the sustainability of the internet

his week saw the launch of Branch magazine, a...

New online magazine Branch explores the sustainability of the internet
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
Four EIT Climate-KIC innovators nominated for EIT Awards

Four EIT Climate-KIC innovators have been nominated to win...

Four EIT Climate-KIC innovators nominated for EIT Awards
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
A LOOP-Ports project Workshop identify and characterise the areas of interven...

Fundación Valenciaport has organised, in the framework of the...

A LOOP-Ports project Workshop identify and characterise the areas of intervention on Circular Economy in Ports
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
Cassetex from Bangladesh, Sosei from Uruguay and Carbon Craft Design from Indi...

More than 3,000 entrepreneurs from 56 countries participated in...

Cassetex from Bangladesh, Sosei from Uruguay and Carbon Craft Design from India win the seventh edition of ClimateLaunchpad
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
EIT Climate-KIC participa con Promálaga en la 11ª edición de Greencities

EIT Climate-KIC junto a la empresa municipal socia Promálaga,...

EIT Climate-KIC participa con Promálaga en la 11ª edición de Greencities
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
bound4blue’s innovative wingsail technology gathers recognition across Europ...

The Spanish start-up Bound4Blue is unstoppable in 2020. Cristina...

bound4blue’s innovative wingsail technology gathers recognition across Europe
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
World’s biggest green business ideas competition now fully digital, free and...

The three-day Grand Global Final of the EIT Climate-KIC supported...

World’s biggest green business ideas competition now fully digital, free and accessible to all
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
Commitment to ensure ‘systematic and structural cooperation’ between the E...

A Letter of Intent was signed today setting out...

Commitment to ensure ‘systematic and structural cooperation’ between the EIC and the EIT
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
Three cities building back better: Madrid, Milan and Amsterdam

EIT Climate-KIC will host a session at the 18th...

Three cities building back better: Madrid, Milan and Amsterdam
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
EIT Climate-KIC to work with Google on Impact Challenge

EIT Climate-KIC is delighted to announce that it will...

EIT Climate-KIC to work with Google on Impact Challenge
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
EIT Climate-KIC’s case studies on innovative land use set the stage for tran...

EIT Climate-KIC launches ‘Innovations in land use,’ a collection...

EIT Climate-KIC’s case studies on innovative land use set the stage for transforming whole systems
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
What role can finance play in the green recovery? EIT Climate-KIC and UNEP Fin...

EIT Climate-KIC, in partnership with the UNEP Finance Initiative,...

What role can finance play in the green recovery? EIT Climate-KIC and UNEP Finance Initiative ask leading thinkers to weigh in
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
The City Finance Lab calls on urban leaders to help build back better

Organised by sustainability expert South Pole, the competition for...

The City Finance Lab calls on urban leaders to help build back better
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
EIT Climate-KIC supports European green recovery with €4 million for start-u...

EIT Climate-KIC is investing €4 million in nine climate...

EIT Climate-KIC supports European green recovery with €4 million for start-ups affected by COVID-19
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
Innovate as if the Future Mattered

  Interview with Kirsten Dunlop written by Alssandra Mazzai...

Innovate as if the Future Mattered
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
How public servants can engage unlikely allies to deliver climate policies

This article is written by Juan Azcarate, Deputy director...

How public servants can engage unlikely allies to deliver climate policies
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
How public servants can engage unlikely allies to deliver climate policies

This article is written by Juan Azcarate, Deputy director...

How public servants can engage unlikely allies to deliver climate policies
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
EIT Climate-KIC supported cities – Leuven, Milan, Valencia and Vienna nomina...

Twelve cities are in the final stage of the...

EIT Climate-KIC supported cities – Leuven, Milan, Valencia and Vienna nominated as European Capital of Innovation 2020
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
Valencia, finalist in the awards to be the European Capital of Innovation 2020

It is the only Spanish finalist city Missions València...

Valencia, finalist in the awards to be the European Capital of Innovation 2020
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
Madrid officially signs up to EIT Climate-KIC’s Deep Demonstration of Cl...

Madrid City Council has agreed to join EIT Climate-KIC...

Madrid officially signs up to EIT Climate-KIC’s Deep Demonstration of Clean & Healthy Cities
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
Celsa Monrós: “To make the future Valencian Regional climate law to work, i...

Celsa Monrós is, since August 2019, the new Director...

Celsa Monrós: “To make the future Valencian Regional climate law to work, it must be accepted by both citizens and the economic sector.”
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
A net zero future offers significant opportunities for the European economy, s...

EIT Climate-KIC’s views on the EU 2030 Climate Target...

A net zero future offers significant opportunities for the European economy, society and citizens
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
€8.4 million for innovation projects that stimulate job creation and support...

Eleven climate innovation projects across Europe tackling COVID-19 related...

€8.4 million for innovation projects that stimulate job creation and support a post COVID-19 green recovery
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
A scientist’s opinion: Interview with Cliona Howie Del Rio about systems thi...

The European Science-Media Hub recently published an interview with...

A scientist’s opinion: Interview with Cliona Howie Del Rio about systems thinking
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
What´s new for the agrifood sector with the European Green Deal?

On Wednesday 20 May, the EU Commission presented the...

What´s new for the agrifood sector with the European Green Deal?
CLIMATE-KIC NEWS
The circular economy reaches the electric batteries through the Lions2Life pro...

Lions2Life project has been launched: a European project promoted...

The circular economy reaches the electric batteries through the Lions2Life project